Implementing a program for parents with intellectual disability in Sweden: A feasibility study
Abstract
This thesis examines implementation of an evidence-informed parent education program
for parents with intellectual disability, called Parenting Young Children (PYC), in the
Swedish social services. The empirical studies on which the thesis is based aimed to
evaluate how feasible and successful implementation of PYC has been to date, examining
program fidelity, and the provision of program support. Study I explored perceptions of
competence development and the training process for Swedish program users (support
workers) who participated in monthly peer support groups. Focus groups discussed
experiences of PYC and completed a competency questionnaire on two occasions.
Perceived competence was high and increased over time. PYC peer support groups were
thought to be beneficial for performance evaluation, exchange of information and coping
with problems. However, many reported few opportunities to implement the program.
Study II investigated peer group facilitators’ (Area Coordinators) perceptions of working
in peer support groups. Area Coordinators completed diaries each month after meetings,
recording topics covered, difficulties experienced by the group and general reflections
about peer support. Area Coordinators also attended a focus group. Several opportunities
and barriers to program implementation were perceived within the groups. Interaction
between the peer support groups and the organization/managers was thought to be
particularly important, but difficult to achieve. In Study III fidelity was examined by
tracking frequency of implementation of program activities and teaching approaches in
support workers. Feasibility was explored through questionnaires addressing perceived
program complexity and compatibility in support workers and their managers.
Implementation of PYC was reported to be highly feasible, with overall positive attitudes
to Evidence-Based Practice, good program compatibility and low perceived program
complexity, as well as high satisfaction with implementation support. However, some
behavioural aspects of PYC were rarely reported to be used in practice. Low
implementation intensity was also reported. Study IV aimed to develop a PYC fidelity
measure that included the perspective of program recipients. Two questionnaires were
developed; one measured parents’ perceptions of support workers’ fidelity, the other was
a self-report questionnaire for support workers. Items from the support worker and parent
versions were compared for inter-rater reliability. Parents and support workers both
reported very high fidelity. Scores were consistent over a three month period. Inter-rater
reliability between parents and support workers was, however, only fair. Taken together,
these results highlight enthusiasm and perceived need for PYC in the social services.
Further work is needed in order to assist implementation of PYC and to develop both the
program itself and program support
Parts of work
I. Mc Hugh, E., & Starke, M. (2015). Understanding support workers’ competence development in working with parents with intellectual disability. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities, 19(4), 326-341. ::doi::10.1177/1744629515576045 II. Mc Hugh, E., & Starke, M. (2016). Supporting implementation of an Evidence-Informed Program using peer support groups: Area Coordinators’ perceptions and experiences. Manuscript submitted for publication. III. Mc Hugh, E., & Starke, M. (2016). Investigating feasibility and fidelity of the Parenting Young Children program in Sweden. Manuscript submitted for publication. IV. Mc Hugh, E., & Starke, M. (2016). Measuring program fidelity: Including the perspective of parents with intellectual disability. Manuscript in preparation
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
University
Göteborgs universitet. Samhällsvetenskapliga fakulteten
University of Gothenburg. Faculty of Social Sciences
Institution
Department of Psychology ; Psykologiska institutionen
Disputation
kl 10:00, Sal F1, Psykologiska institutionen, Haraldsgatan 1, Göteborg.
Date of defence
2016-12-16
elaine.mc.hugh@socwork.gu.se
Date
2016-11-17Author
Mc Hugh, Elaine
Keywords
evidence-informed programs
intellectual disability
implementation
program fidelity
Parenting Young Children
feasibility
Publication type
Doctoral thesis
ISBN
978-91-629-0013-7 (PDF)
978-91-629-0014-4 (Print)
ISSN
1101-718X
Series/Report no.
Doctoral Dissertation
Language
eng