Why Not Bypass?
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
By using a nested analysis strategy, this thesis examines what explains Tanzania's deviation from the general trend of increased bypass in Swedish aid delivery. The quantitative analysis finds that, while the relationship between lower levels of democracy/quality of government and less aid channeled through the public sector is supported in the case of Sweden, Tanzania's break from the general trend of increased bypass cannot alone be explained by the level of democracy and quality of government. This puzzle further guides a small-N case study analysing Tanzania alongside two shadow cases – Burkina Faso and Mozambique – that followed the general trend of increased bypass. The comparison is used to qualitatively assess the conditions and mechanisms beyond the standard predictors such as democracy and quality of government that may explain why Tanzania did not follow the general trend. To achieve this, data is collected through key informant interviews with Swedish aid officials, complemented by Swedish strategy reports. While the literature has mainly focused on quality of government as the primary explanatory variable, some scholars point to what other factors – such as strategic, relational and sector-level considerations – that may condition the democracy/quality of government and bypass link. However, the literature remains limited both in its ability to assess these factors jointly across cases and in its examination of processes through which additional factors affect levels of bypass. The analysis identifies three explanations to Tanzania's deviation from the general trend. Firstly, Sweden focused on Tanzanian sectors in which government institutions were viewed as crucial partners to achieve results which generated low substitutability of non-state aid channels. Secondly, the sectors where Sweden provided aid was deemed less affected by governance risks, meaning that risks of aid not reaching its intended targets were not generalised across all state sectors. Lastly, Sweden was able to minimise governance risks in the educational sector while continuing channelling aid through the public sector by providing aid once development targets in the sector were met and necessary reforms were in place. This provides in-depth insight into what factors and mechanisms help explain deviations in the democracy/quality of government and bypass link and suggests that donors' aid allocation decisions may also be affected by additional factors at the sector level.