Political conflicts - Dissent and antagonism among political parties in local government
Abstract
Political conflicts arise out of, or are at least nourished by, divisions and tensions in society over how resources are distributed between citizens and social groups. In the parliamentary arena, these conflicts are manifested by political parties representing the interests of their voters. However, even though we may agree that political conflicts are essential for politics and democratic systems, there is no consensus on what political conflicts are, what causes conflict and what their effects are. This thesis develops a theoretical framework for political conflicts that is productive in relation to studying causes and effects of political conflicts in local governments. A multi-method approach is applied in the studies. The first three papers and a literature review that is included in the introductory text focus on causes of political conflicts. The literature review, as well as the first paper, centres on structural and organisa-tional explanations. The literature review focuses on the research question: How did Swedish local governments develop into party politicised forms of government, with the first paper dealing with the research question: What are the causes of political conflicts identified by earlier scholars and what effects do they have on local politics? The second paper focuses solely on organisational explanations and examines the research question: How does the organisation of political systems affect how and where political conflicts are expressed? The third paper uses explanations at the individual level and deals with the research question: How do ideology, partisanship and trust affect how political conflicts are perceived? The fourth and final paper focuses on the effects of conflicts and answers the research question: To what extent does party political conflicts affect the influence of political leaders? The findings show that there are at least two forms of political conflict of relevance for parliamentary arenas – political dissent and antagonistic behaviour – and that it is important to distinguish between them. They have different characteristics, are caused by different factors and produce different effects. Manifestations of political dissent clarify differences between political actors and are thus of great importance to a democratic system. However, an overinflated amount of antagonistic and disrespectful behaviour, on the other hand, will create a problematic political working environment. When antagonism turns ugly, democratic institutions and the actors working within them may lose their legitimacy.
Parts of work
Paper I: Skoog, L. & D. Karlsson (2018) Causes of party conflicts in local politics. Politics, 38(2), pp. 182-196. ::doi::10.177/026339571667878 Paper II: Skoog, L. Where did the party conflicts go? How horizontal specialisation in political systems affects party conflicts. Paper III: Skoog, L. & D. Karlsson. Conflicting estimations of conflict - How politicians’ perceptions of party conflicts are explained by ideology, partisanship and trust. Paper IV: Skoog, L. & D. Karlsson (2015) Politiska konflikter och marknadisering – utmaningar för politiska ledare? In Aarsæther, N. & K. Mikalsen (Eds.), Lokalpolitisk lederskap i Norden (pp. 112-147). Oslo: Gyldendal Akademisk.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
University
Göteborgs universitet. Samhällsvetenskapliga fakulteten
University of Gothenburg. Faculty of Social Sciences
Institution
School of Public Administration ; Förvaltningshögskolan
Disputation
Fredagen den 1 februari 2019, kl. 13:15, Hörsal Dragonen, Sprängkullsgatan 19
Date of defence
2019-02-01
louise.skoog@spa.gu.se
Date
2019-01-09Author
Skoog, Louise
Keywords
democracy
political conflict
party conflict
political dissent
antagonistic behaviour
multi-methods
local government
local politics
political parties
causes of conflict
effects of conflicts
Publication type
Doctoral thesis
ISBN
978-91-984547-6-5 (print)
978-91-984547-7-2 (online version)
Language
eng
Metadata
Show full item recordRelated items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Challenges for the Democratisation Process in Tanzania. Moving Towards Consolidation 50 years after independence?
Ewald, Jonas (2011-11-28)Tanzania has been independent in 2011 for 50 years. While most neighbouring states have gone through violent conflicts, Tanzania has managed to implement extensive reforms without armed political conflicts. Hence, Tanzania ... -
Vulnerable EU Migrants' access to Welfare - A source of Conflict? A Comparative Study of Party-Political Approaches in Gothenburg and Stockholm
Wadstein, Maja (2016-10-04)Vulnerable EU migrants' access to welfare has become a controversial issue in Sweden since two rounds of EU Eastern enlargement. The political debate has comprised both inclusive and welfare protective preferences, however, ... -
QUALITY OF GOVERMENT AND INTERNAL CONFLICT A large N study of developing countries
Pettersson, Fredrik (2018-09-14)This thesis examines the effect of quality of government on low-intensity internal conflict, and how this relationship could be conditioned by the extent of ethnic division, in a context of developing and newly industrialised ...