Modal Empiricism Made Difficult: An Essay in the Meta-Epistemology of Modality
Philosophers have always taken an interest not only in what is actually the case, but in what is necessarily the case and what could possibly be the case. These are questions of modality. Epistemologists of modality enquire into how we can know what is necessary and what is possible. This dissertation concerns the meta-epistemology of modality. It engages with the rules that govern construction and evaluation of theories in the epistemology of mo¬dality, by using modal empiricism – a form of modal epistemology – as a running example. In particular, I investigate the assumption that it is important to be able to meet the integration challenge. Meeting the integration challenge is a source of serious difficulty for many approaches, but modal empiricism is supposed to do well in this respect. But I argue that once we have a better grasp of what the integration challenge is, it is not obvious that it presents no problem for modal empiricism. Moreover, even if modal empiricism could be said to be in a relatively good position with respect to integration, it comes at the cost of a forced choice between far-reaching partial modal scepticism and non-uniformism about the epistemology of modality. Non-uniformism is the view that more than one modal epistemology will be correct. While non-uniformism might not in itself be unpalatable, it must be defined and defended in a way which squares with the modal empiricist’s other commitment. I explore two ways of doing so, both involving a revised idea of the integration challenge and its role for the epistemology of modality. One involves a bifurcation of the integration challenge, and the other a restriction of the integration challenge’s relevance. Both ways are interesting, but neither is, as it turns out, a walk in the park.
Doctor of Philosophy
Göteborgs universitet. Humanistiska fakulteten
University of Gothenburg. Faculty of Arts
Department of Philosophy, Linguistics and Theory of Science ; Institutionen för filosofi, lingvistik och vetenskapsteori
Fredagen den 8 februari 2019, kl. 13.15, T302, Gamla Hovrätten, Olof Wijksgatan 6
Date of defence
Sjölin Wirling, Ylwa
epistemology of modality
metaphysics of modality
Acta Philosophica Gothoburgensis
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Invoking the modal nymph: The emergence and dissemination of the concept of modality in Swedish folk music Huebscher, Netta (2022-09-02)Since the emergence of a concept of folk music, the study and practice of certain Western European musical traditions has been informed by notions of the music’s modality. Specifically, the idea that older or more indigenous ...
Lehnér, Jakob Rymark; Segerlund, Daniel (2014-12-11)Co-modality was first introduced in 2006 by the European Commission, the definition was stated as “the efficient use of different transport modes on their own or in combination will result in an optimal and sustainable ...
Jonsson, Jakob (2017-09-27)This essay describes a method, developed by the author, in order to suggest logical ways for modal progression, based on the number of common notes and tone- collection characteristics. Apart from the exposition of the ...