Decision making on indoor climate control in historic buildings: knowledge, uncertainty and the science-practice gap
Balancing use, preservation and energy use is a fundamental challenge for the whole heritage field. This is put to the point in designing and operating systems for indoor climate control in historic buildings, where competing objectives such as preservation, comfort, accessibility, energy use and cost have to be negotiated in the individual case. The overarching aim of this thesis is to explore the gap between research and practice regarding energy efficient indoor climate control in historic buildings. The thesis deals with historic buildings where both the building fabric and the movable collection are vulnerable and where the management of the building is more or less professionalized. Examples of such buildings are palaces, churches and historic house museums, ranging from the large and complex to the small and simple. A key to a more sustainable management of these buildings is to understand how scientific knowledge related to indoor climate control can become usable for the professional practitioner. The thesis comprises six published papers introduced by a thesis essay. The papers reflect a progression both in terms of the research questions and the methodology. The first three papers outline the background needed for a technical understanding of the involved matters through an identification of key knowledge gaps. The three remaining papers use qualitative case studies to understand the nature of the gap between science and practice by paying more attention to the social aspects of decisions related to indoor climate control. Generally, the results of the thesis contribute to an expanded problem definition and to a better understanding of the gap between research and practice regarding energy efficient indoor climate control in historic buildings. It is shown how the specific social and material context is crucial for enabling or limiting a transition toward more sustainable ways of controlling the indoor climate. Furthermore it is discussed how uncertainty can be managed and communicated to support decisions, and suggestions are given for how decision processes regarding indoor climate control can be supported with improved standards to facilitate a more sustainable management. A conclusion for further research is that scientific knowledge alone will not be able to guide the transition to a sustainable, low carbon future; technical esearch has to be complemented with reflexive research approaches that explore the actual practices of heritage management.
Parts of work
Leijonhufvud, G. and Bylund-Melin, C. 2009. ”Preventive conservation climate in historic buildings – some gaps in the knowledge”. “Bevarandeklimat i historiska byggnader-Några kunskapsluckor.” Meddelser om konservering no 1 2009, p. 22-30.Leijonhufvud, G., Kjellström, E., Broström, T., Ashley-Smith, J. and Camuffo, D. 2013. “Uncertainties in damage assessments of future indoor climates.” In: Climate for collections: Standards and uncertainties. Edited by Ashley-Smith, J., Burmester, A. and Eibl, M. 405–18. London: Archetype Publications.Broström, T. and Leijonhufvud, G. 2010. “The indoor climate in Skokloster Castle.” In Historical buildings as museums: Systems for climate control and heritage preservation. Edited by Del Curto, D., 84–93. Firenze: Nardini Editore.Leijonhufvud, G. and Henning, A. 2014. “Rethinking indoor climate control in historic buildings: The importance of negotiated priorities and discursive hegemony at a Swedish museum.” Energy Research & Social Science 4 (0): 117-23. ::doi::10.1016/j.erss.2014.10.005Leijonhufvud, G. 2016. “Making sense of climate risk information: the case of future indoor climate risks in Swedish churches.” Climate Risk Management. ::doi::10.1016/j.crm.2016.05.003Leijonhufvud, G. and Broström, T. “Standardizing the indoor climate in Swedish churches: opportunities, challenges and ways forward.” Manuscript.
Doctor of Philosophy
Göteborgs universitet. Naturvetenskapliga fakulteten
Department of Conservation ; Institutionen för kulturvård
Måndagen den 3 oktober 2016, kl. 13.00, Institutionen för kulturvård, Hörsalen, Geovetarcentrum, Guldhedsgatan 5c, Göteborg.
Date of defence
Gothenburg studies in conservation, 36